What Retailers Are Buying in the FedEx Same-Day Deal

Amazon launched one-hour and three-hour delivery options last week. FedEx responded Tuesday by announcing a same-day partnership with last-mile delivery software company OneRail, which CNBC reported exclusively. The two announcements are part of the same competitive pressure, but they reflect very different structural positions, and the distance between them is exactly what the FedEx-OneRail deal is being sold to close.

What the Partnership Provides

The service, called FedEx SameDay Local according to Reuters, gives retailers access to OneRail’s network of more than 1,000 carriers without requiring them to build or own that infrastructure. OneRail told CNBC the platform covers nearly 99% of the U.S. and claims access to 12 million gig economy drivers across its carrier network, currently handling 80,000 deliveries of 30 minutes or less per day. Retailers can offer customers two-hour delivery windows or end-of-day options, with near real-time tracking throughout.

The pricing structure places decisions with the retailer. OneRail provides a rate card, and each retailer sets its own same-day shipping prices within its own checkout. FedEx senior vice president of digital Jason Brenner told CNBC that the model’s core advantage is what it removes from the retailer’s operational plate. “It’s very complex to manage if you stitch it together yourself,” Brenner said. “It’s very costly to manage, and it’s very complex and costly to scale.” OneRail CEO Bill Catania told CNBC the structure preserves something retailers are increasingly protective of in third-party fulfillment arrangements: “It unlocks even more capabilities for the retailer, which really lets them own their customer and their data.”

Catania told CNBC the partnership has been in development for several years, with the timing reflecting conditions in the current market rather than a rushed response to Amazon’s announcement.

What Amazon Built That FedEx Is Not Replicating

Understanding what the FedEx-OneRail deal offers requires understanding what it is not. Amazon’s one-to-three-hour delivery runs through a dedicated network of same-day fulfillment sites that handle the full order lifecycle under one roof. Amazon senior vice president of worldwide operations Udit Madan said in the company’s announcement that the new options build on those facilities alongside predictive AI inventory placement algorithms developed over years of same-day investment. More than 90,000 products are currently eligible. One-hour delivery is available in hundreds of U.S. cities; three-hour delivery covers more than 2,000 locations. Prime members pay $9.99 for one-hour delivery and $4.99 for three-hour, while non-members pay $19.99 and $14.99 respectively.

That infrastructure represents two decades of capital investment and a loyalty program with the pricing power to subsidize speed for its most valuable customers. Walmart has reached a comparable position through its store network. On its February earnings call, Walmart reported that fast delivery, defined as under three hours, grew more than 60% last year, and the retailer can now reach about 95% of U.S. households at that speed, according to Axios. Target told Axios it offers same-day delivery in three hours or less to about 80% of the U.S. population. Both retailers spent years converting their store footprints into fulfillment nodes before those numbers became possible.

What FedEx and OneRail are offering is access to a third-party network rather than ownership of an integrated one. The operational complexity Brenner described as prohibitive for retailers building same-day capability themselves does not disappear in the FedEx-OneRail model. It transfers to a shared platform, with the economics and service quality that entails rather than those of a proprietary network.

What the Economics Require Retailers to Work Out

The rate card model preserves retailer flexibility on pricing but concentrates a specific risk. A retailer that prices same-day delivery too high relative to Amazon or Walmart will not drive adoption among the customers most likely to use the service. One that prices it too low to attract shoppers may find the unit economics unworkable at scale, particularly outside dense urban markets where driver networks are thinner and route efficiency drops.

Consumer demand patterns sharpen that calculation. A McKinsey survey of more than 1,000 U.S. consumers found that on-time reliability ranks as a significantly more important factor than the availability of same-day delivery, and that 90% of consumers are willing to wait two or three days for deliveries if it allows them to avoid shipping costs. For brands and retailers evaluating the FedEx-OneRail offering, that finding suggests same-day delivery will drive conversion in specific categories and for specific customer segments without functioning as a universal fulfillment upgrade. Investing in the reliability and visibility of any delivery window may return more than compressing the window itself across most of the assortment.

For retailers in categories where immediacy genuinely drives purchase decisions, including over-the-counter health products, consumables, and time-sensitive specialty items, a same-day option accessible without infrastructure investment addresses a real competitive gap. Brenner told CNBC the platform also accommodates larger items such as furniture, where customers may need specific delivery windows, which extends the use case beyond the categories Amazon’s network currently handles best.

Who This Deal Is For

The competitive pressure Amazon’s launch creates is not uniform across retail. For large-format general merchandise retailers with existing store-fulfilled delivery networks, the near-term challenge is optimizing speed within an infrastructure they already operate. For mid-market specialty retailers, regional chains, and brands selling direct to consumers without Amazon’s or Walmart’s logistics foundation, the implication is that same-day delivery is shifting from a competitive differentiator toward a baseline expectation in the categories where Amazon and Walmart have concentrated their fastest networks.

GlobalData retail analyst Neil Saunders, speaking to CBS News about Amazon’s launch last week, noted the pressure falls hardest on specific categories. Amazon’s combination of price and delivery speed is “bad news for drugstores in particular,” he said, given the overlap with everyday staples those retailers depend on for traffic. For specialty and mid-market retailers outside the drugstore category, the dynamic Saunders describes is the same one the FedEx-OneRail rate card model asks them to price against, in categories where Amazon’s cost and speed advantages are built into infrastructure they do not own.

Conversations On Retail

Conversations On Retail is a gathering place and resource center for retail and CPG executives, built to make it easier to stay current, discover the technologies and solutions shaping the industry, and connect with the people driving it forward.

We publish news, views, and reviews from staff editors, contributing experts, and trusted partners. Some articles are developed internally, while others are submitted by industry contributors or adapted from interviews and recorded conversations with industry leaders.