Retail’s Quiet Warning Shot: Why 2025’s Seasonal Hiring Is Setting Off Alarms

A Historic Pullback in Seasonal Hiring

A new report from Challenger, Gray & Christmas predicts that retail’s seasonal hiring additions in the final quarter of 2025 will fall below 500,000 roles, the weakest gain since the recession year of 2009 and roughly 8% below last year’s seasonal hiring.

In past years, companies such as Target, Macy’s, Burlington, Aldi, and 1-800-Flowers had already announced large seasonal staffing plans by this point. This year, many remain silent. Target has emphasized giving current employees more hours and leaning on its “On-Demand team” of 43,000 associates rather than publishing a seasonal hiring figure. Spirit Halloween and Bath & Body Works are among the few to set public targets, with Spirit holding steady at 50,000 hires and Bath & Body Works planning 32,000, slightly fewer than last year.

Seasonal hiring has always been more than a staffing exercise. It is also a barometer of how confident retailers feel about holiday demand. The slower pace of announcements suggests companies are preparing for a muted season.

What’s Driving the Cutbacks?

Margin Squeezes from Inflation and Tariffs

Costs remain elevated. Inflation hasn’t fully retreated, and tariffs are working through supply chains. Many retailers are raising prices to protect margins, but the added pressure makes them less willing to commit to large staffing increases.

Automation and Leaner Operating Models

Retailers have invested heavily in automation, robotics, and self-checkout systems. These tools reduce the need for seasonal surges in labor, allowing companies to stretch permanent teams further.

Consumer Caution

Shoppers are planning to spend less. PwC’s 2025 Holiday Outlook found consumers expect to cut overall holiday spending by 5%, with an 11% reduction on gifts specifically. AlixPartners is forecasting only 3% to 5% retail growth this season, while Deloitte’s forecast is in the same restrained range. These signals point to a more cautious consumer, and retailers are planning accordingly.

Labor Market Dynamics

Hiring has become harder and more expensive. Wage pressures remain, and many seasonal workers are turning to more flexible or better-paying opportunities outside traditional retail. Longer hiring timelines and a shrinking candidate pool are pushing companies to rethink how many roles they can realistically fill.

Strategic Conservatism

Rather than front-load hiring, some retailers may be waiting to see how early-season sales unfold before adding staff. This strategy allows flexibility but risks being caught short-handed during peak weeks.

How Retailers Are Adapting

• Building flexible staffing pools that can shift across functions
• Offering more hours to existing associates instead of bringing in new staff
• Using staffing platforms and temp agencies for last-minute coverage
• Hiring early only for critical roles with long lead times
• Cross-training employees to handle multiple responsibilities
• Retaining strong seasonal performers for next year or converting them to permanent roles
• Using data-driven forecasting to adjust staffing closer to real-time

Risks and Opportunities for the Holidays

If demand exceeds expectations, understaffed stores could see longer lines, slower replenishment, and weaker service at the very moment shoppers are most valuable. Last-minute hiring at premium wages is an expensive fallback.

On the other hand, leaner teams could help preserve margins if sales remain soft. Retailers that use flexible staffing, analytics, and omnichannel fulfillment to their advantage may keep service levels high without the burden of excess labor.

Looking Ahead

The sharp pullback in seasonal hiring is more than a quirk of timing. It signals caution about the health of holiday spending and reflects the ongoing tension between cost control and customer service. Retailers that manage this balancing act well—using smarter staffing, technology, and flexibility—may not only protect margins this season but also establish more resilient labor models for the future.

Conversations On Retail

Conversations On Retail is a gathering place and resource center for retail and CPG executives, built to make it easier to stay current, discover the technologies and solutions shaping the industry, and connect with the people driving it forward.

We publish news, views, and reviews from staff editors, contributing experts, and trusted partners. Some articles are developed internally, while others are submitted by industry contributors or adapted from interviews and recorded conversations with industry leaders.